Legal Egale

Book Reviewer Kadam Swaraj Jitendra B.A. LL. B IV Bharati Vidyapeeth’s Yashwantrao Chavan Law College karad
Indu Bhan’s Legal Eagles is a fascinating tribute to the brilliance and determination of eight legal luminaries who have shaped the Indian legal landscape. Through a compelling narrative, the book captures the essence of their professional journeys, personal struggles, and landmark contributions to the Indian judiciary. This is not just a book about the law; it’s a window into the minds of individuals who have dedicated their lives to the pursuit of justice.
The book begins with a detailed account of Fali S. Nariman, widely regarded as one of India’s greatest constitutional experts. Nariman’s career is a testament to unwavering principles and intellectual brilliance. From his involvement in the historic Kesavananda Bharati case, which defined the “basic structure doctrine,” to his contributions to arbitration law, Nariman’s story is inspiring. Indu Bhan portrays him as a legal giant who chose integrity over convenience, even when it meant taking tough decisions. His advocacy for secularism and the rule of law serves as a guiding light in today’s turbulent times.
The spotlight then shifts to Harish Salve, a name synonymous with high-profile cases and international advocacy. Salve’s transformation from a chartered accountant to one of the most sought-after lawyers in India is nothing short of extraordinary. His handling of cases like the Vodafone tax dispute and India’s representation in the Kulbhushan Jadhav case at the International Court of Justice reflect his sharp legal mind and meticulous preparation. What stands out in Salve’s profile is his ability to adapt and evolve, embracing global legal trends while staying rooted in Indian law.
Mukul Rohatgi, another legal stalwart, comes alive in the pages of Legal Eagles. Rohatgi’s tenure as the Attorney General of India was marked by fearless and pragmatic advocacy. His handling of complex constitutional and corporate cases showcases his command over diverse areas of law. Bhan presents Rohatgi as a lawyer who thrives under pressure, using his charisma and courtroom presence to make compelling arguments. His journey reminds readers that confidence, combined with expertise, can achieve remarkable results.
The book would be incomplete without a tribute to Ram Jethmalani, a legendary figure in Indian legal history. Known for his audacious courtroom style and sharp wit, Jethmalani was a maverick who pushed boundaries. From defending notorious criminals to challenging the establishment, his career was as controversial as it was illustrious. Bhan captures his larger-than-life persona, highlighting his unrelenting pursuit of justice and his commitment to defending the rights of the marginalized. Jethmalani’s story is a powerful reminder of the role of dissent and courage in the legal profession.
Among the less celebrated but equally impactful figures in the book is Gopal Subramanium. His profile reflects a deep commitment to constitutional values and an unwavering belief in the sanctity of the judiciary. From his work in the Godhra riots case to his tenure as the Solicitor General of India, Subramanium’s career has been marked by integrity and dedication. Bhan brings out his human side, showing a man who stood firm in the face of political pressure and personal challenges.
KK Venugopal, another towering figure, has been a guiding force in constitutional law. As the Attorney General of India, Venugopal’s vast knowledge and measured approach have earned him respect across the legal fraternity. Bhan delves into his meticulous preparation and ability to simplify complex legal arguments, making him a true icon of the Indian bar. His story is one of quiet strength and enduring commitment to the rule of law.
Ashok Desai, whose contributions to administrative law are unparalleled, also finds a place in the book. Bhan highlights his tenure as the Solicitor General and his role in several landmark cases. Desai’s profile is a reminder of the unsung heroes of the legal world, whose work may not always grab headlines but leaves a lasting impact on the judiciary.
Finally, the book explores the legacy of **T.R. Andhyarujina**, a constitutional law expert whose deep understanding of legal principles made him a formidable advocate. Bhan’s portrayal of Andhyarujina emphasizes his intellectual rigor and his contributions to some of the most significant cases in Indian legal history. His work serves as an example of how thorough research and logical reasoning can elevate the practice of law.
What sets Legal Eagles apart is its humanizing approach to these legal titans. Bhan doesn’t just focus on their professional achievements but also delves into their personal lives, revealing the sacrifices and challenges they faced. Whether it’s Nariman choosing principle over profit, Salve juggling his international commitments, or Subramanium standing firm against political interference, these stories inspire readers to pursue excellence while staying true to their values.
The book also doesn’t shy away from addressing the controversies surrounding some of these advocates. For instance, it discusses criticisms of Salve’s high fees and Jethmalani’s decision to take up unpopular cases. This balanced approach adds depth to the narrative, presenting these legal icons as humans with strengths and flaws.
However, the book is not without its shortcomings. Some profiles feel rushed, leaving readers wanting more detail about certain landmark cases. Additionally, the absence of female legal luminaries is a noticeable gap, especially given the contributions of women like Indira Jaising and Menaka Guruswamy to Indian law. Including their stories would have made the book more representative of the diverse voices in the legal profession.
Despite these limitations, Legal Eagles is a must-read for law students, legal professionals, and anyone interested in India’s judiciary. It serves as both a source of inspiration and a valuable resource, offering insights into the lives of those who have shaped the nation’s legal framework. Indu Bhan’s meticulous research and engaging writing make the book accessible to readers from all backgrounds, ensuring that it resonates with a wide audience.
In conclusion, Legal Eagles is more than just a collection of profiles; it is a celebration of the power of the law and the individuals who dedicate their lives to upholding it. Through their stories, readers are reminded of the importance of integrity, perseverance, and the relentless pursuit of justice. Indu Bhan’s work stands as a testament to the enduring legacy of these legal titans and their invaluable contributions to Indian jurisprudence.